Bad Credit Loans

Canadian Dividend Stocks Are Flexing Muscles Too

[tags]General,,[/tags]

Add to Onlywire

As mentioned in my High Yielding Dividend Stocks Flexing Muscles post, 12 independent studies concluded that investing in high yielding dividend stocks was a winning strategy for much of the previous century. Despite the overwhelming evidence, all the studies were predominantly US and UK based, so I decided to roll up my sleeves and conduct my own research in Canada.

To begin, I queried for all Canadian dividend mutual funds with at least 15-years of historical data from GlobeFund. I then manually weed out funds with too much bond or foreign content; so, only dividend funds with at least 75% common stocks, and 80% Canadian contents made the list.

Here are the final 7 funds along with their 15-year compounded return and Management Expense Ratio (MER):

1. PH&N Dividend Income (Return=14.28%, MER=1.11%)
2. RBC Canadian Dividend (Return=13.08%, MER=1.73%)
3. Scotia Canadian Dividend (Return=12.03%, MER=1.67%)
4. TD Dividend Growth (Return=11.51%, MER=1.94%)
5. CIBC Dividend (Return=9.37%, MER=1.96%)
6. Investors Dividend (Return=8.27%, MER=2.87%)
7. Mavrix Dividend & Income (Return=8.08%, MER=2.14%)

Not surprisingly, lower MER funds tend to churn out stronger performance over time. However, I don’t see the benefit of paying for MER when an investor can easily emulate these dividend funds with a handful of core holdings, and then build on them as the portfolio grows.

The average annual return for the group is 10.95%, but if I remove the MER component, gross return jumps to 12.87%. It’s worth reiterating that a typical dividend fund has a bond allocation, so a pure dividend play would see over 13% in return. For comparison, TSX’s total return over the same period is 11.27% before tracking error, or a difference of 1.60+% compounded over 15 years. Over the next 3 years or so, I anticipate financial stocks to rebound and resource stocks to cool, which would widen the lead even more.

For other benefits of dividend investing, please check out my post on Top 10 Reasons For Dividend Investing.